Tooth Fairy
Back to Supporting Cast Main > Tooth Fairy
Real Identity: Tooth Fairy
Affiliations: Teen Titans
Appearances: Dignity of Teeth, The Streak: Pt 2, Easter Creeps, Career Day, The Academy, Ship, Catpin Freak, 50% Crew, Five Bucks, and Wild Card
Powers/Skills: Flight and Magic
Voiced By: Khary Payton
The Tooth Fairy is a supernatural being known for giving money to those who place their loose teeth under their pillows overnight. One of her other quirks was saying "Ta-ta-ra-ta-ta" with most of her sentences. Unknown to anyone, she ate the teeth. She thought it was what everyone did. Raven thought the fairy was a creep and refused to give any of her teeth. As a result, the Tooth Fairy coveted her teeth even more. Beast Boy, however, did and became overcome with greed. The other Titans followed in suit despite Raven's warning that teeth is the source of a person's dignity. In due time, the Titans sold all their teeth and tried to take Raven's. She had enough and teleported them to the Tooth Fairy's lair - a large tooth modified into a house - somewhere in a rundown part of Jump City. The Tooth Fairy refused to give the Titans' teeth back for nothing and proposed a trade - theirs for Raven's. Raven naturally refused.
Tooth Fairy proposed a game. If she won, she got Raven's teeth. If Raven won, she got the Titans' teeth back. Raven accepted. Tooth Fairy chose a tooth eating competition. Thinking of her friends, Raven ate a tooth and discovered it was really good. Tooth Fairy was shocked at how fast Raven was eating teeth. At the end, she was too full and lost to Raven. Raven apologized to Tooth Fairy for misjudging her as a creep. Tooth Fairy understood and gave the teeth back but admitted to Raven she already ate one of Beast Boy's. Raven was pretty sure he wouldn't miss it. During Crime Season, Beast Boy recruited the Tooth Fairy to join the Teen Titans after Kid Flash pinched Cyborg, Starfire, and Raven for his own team. She admitted would do it for teeth and she was looking under Robin's pillow the previous night. In a battle against Dr. Light, Robin got creamed and lost teeth. Tooth Fairy couldn't resist and started eating them.
The Tooth Fairy realized the Easter Bunny wasn't leaving chocolate eggs for Easter anymore so no one was losing their teeth. She consulted her recipe book and made her own chocolate eggs with extra sugar. Robin was suspicious of the delivery at first but the Titans gorged on the eggs and lost their teeth. The Tooth Fairy soon arrived to collect. The Titans were unable to fight back. She threw molars, incisors, and canines at them then left in the elevator. The Titans tried to train the Easter Bunny but opted to give him a makeover that made him look tough. He ordered the Tooth Fairy to step off. They soon became attracted to each other and fell in love. They shared the holiday and spreed Easter cheer throughout the city then decided to start a family. Junior hatched from one of the Easter Bunny's eggs. Tooth Fairy went to Raven's general dentistry practice for a teeth cleaning. Sticky Joe and the Tooth Fairy were presents for "Best Dishwasher" at the first annual Teen Titan Awards.
The Tooth Fairy accepted Starfire's offer to join her mission to Tamaran to surprise her sister Blackfire. In the sleeping quarters, there was a hospital bed for Tooth Fairy. She found it just right. Starfire made Tooth Fairy the chief officer of the medicine. Folding Paper Man fainted at the sight of the blob outside. Starfire wanted Tooth Fairy's assistance in tending to him but 50% Chad pointed out she was out in space. Starfire wondered how she got out into space. Platz nonchalantly admitted he did it because Tooth Fairy creeped him out so he issued her a space time-out for a little bit. Starfire asked him to bring her back in. Freaky pointed out the blog got her. 50% Chad fired lasers at half-power but they had no effect. Starfire decided they had to go outside to retrieve her. They, too, ended up in the blob and attacked in vain. Folding Paper Man turned himself into a paper airplane and transported everyone back to the Ship. Starfire was all but ready to give up but Platz gave her one last option, the Cadmium Thermabomb but when detonated, nothing would survive its power.
Everyone made peace with making the ultimate sacrifice but it was just a prank by Platz. Confetti dropped on them and he cleared the smushed bug with water and a windshield wiper. Platz felt entitled to some fun since he had to haul them around. The bug's angry giant mother found the ship in space. No one believed Platz. She swallowed it whole. 50% Chad came up with a half-baked idea to escape. He and the Tooth Fairy made their way to the mouth. Tooth Fairy lodged her crowbar Steenburgen under a tooth on the bug's bottom row. 50% Chad leaped off the top row and landed on the crowbar. The tooth popped out and the bug barfed the ship, Tooth Fairy, and Chad out into space. The ship gathered them up and took off with the bug in hot pursuit. Folding Paper Man completed a giant paper version of the baby bug and launched into space. The bug teared up, hugged it, weeped, kissed it, and left with it. The crew cheered. Platz admitted he underestimated them and declared they were all right in his book then announced a celebration. He hugged them with robot arms and turned on the disco balls and music. There was a tapping on the glass. Starfire couldn't believe Platz ejected Tooth Fairy into space again. Platz didn't see what the problem was.
During the Moon Flower mission, Tooth Fairy could not resist a Skullbot's teeth and pulled one out from the upper jaw. The Skullbot angrily activated. Tooth Fairy tried in vain to put the tooth back. It chased Tooth and the rest of the crew while firing eye lasers. Freak directed them to take cover behind a junk pile but it was for an ice cream party. Folding Paper Man didn't think it was the time for a party but Freak folded him into a paper hat and put him on Starfire's head. He demanded three scoops of Superman ice cream with sprinkles. Tooth Fairy couldn't think of what she wanted but Freak pressed on and she asked for a tooth sundae with extra teeth and little toothy sprinkles. Freak gagged and ordered a Choco with sprinkly then dropped it on her head. Tooth Fairy's right arm got mangled by some alien dogs guarding the junkyard. She was angry at first but noticed several of their teeth came off and were stuck to her arm. She munched on one.
Seven space days into the journey, Starfire's crew located the Celestial Sugar Crystal, the second rare item on her list. The crew took it literally and Tooth Fairy's sweet tooth was watering. Due to a teleporter incident, they lost the top halves of their bodies. Starfire tried to keep them calm and suggested faux heads for the time being. Tooth Fairy used a pillow with a face drawn on she called Ginger Vitis. Every idea led to failure but the destruction of the engine activated Security Bot 5, a robot installed by Platz to protect The Ship from meat sacks. They were forced to go along with Chad's half-baked idea and pretended to be operating a day spa. Tooth Fairy advised it to take it easy and enjoy the moment then put a towel around its neck and rubbed its temples. Security Bot relaxed then talked about how stressful it was to be a bot: crush this, destroy that. It realized it needed me time and friends. It hugged the crew in gratitude and asked how it could return the kindness.
Some time later, Security Bot fixed the teleporter. The top halves of the crew returned and the sugar crystals had been retrieved already. Starfire apologized to Chad but realized their bodies were mixed up. She had Freak's lower torso, Folding Paper Man had Starfire's, Tooth Fairy had Folding Paper Man's, and Freak had Tooth Fairy's. The crew located a Galactic Egg on an asteroid but the surface was too hard for their drill. Tooth Fairy turned her wand into a dentist's drill and successfully revealed the egg. It was still lodged in the asteroid. Folding Paper Man turned himself into a crowbar but the egg would not budge and a piece ricocheted and hit Freaky Face's mouth. His top middle tooth fail off and he threw a tantrum. Starfire opted to have everyone teleported back to The Ship and came back after he calmed down. Tooth Fairy was eager to have the tooth but Freak refused and stomped her. Everyone explained what the Tooth Fairy's job was. She revealed she now left $5 for a tooth instead of a quarter. Everyone happily knocked a tooth out. Freak felt bad and gave one of this teeth to 50% Chad and Platz.
The next morning, everyone was happy to find five dollar bills under their pillows. Chad got it in half dollars while Platz received digital currency. Tooth Fairy lamented she would never know the joy of losing a tooth and getting money for it. She revealed she never lost a tooth because her magic was too strong. Starfire vowed they would help to rectify that. 50% Chad tried a twist on the classic removal via string. Instead of slamming a door on her, he simply kicked her at half strength. It didn't work. He offered to kick harder but she declined. Freak got an idea and dressed her and himself in hockey gear then proceeded to rough house. It didn't work either. Starfire opted to try kind and gentle counseling but it failed and she became angry and tried to pry a tooth out with her hands. Platz offered a simple solution: use the teleporter to isolate a tooth and beam the rest of her away. It worked. Starfire ordered Platz to teleport the Tooth Fairy out of space and back onboard. They tucked Tooth Fairy in for the night.
The loss of the tooth caused her magic to fall out of alignment and she turned into an angry Tooth Monster. The next morning, to add insult to injury, the others found out Folding Paper Man gave her a nickel instead of five dollars. She demanded her tooth back but Freak couldn't remember what he did with it. They were chased throughout the Ship until he remembered he ate it. Folding Paper Man was pressured to folding himself into a substitute tooth. She accepted but he found it too gross and forced her to spit him out. Platz guided them to the teleporter room so they could beam the tooth back into Tooth Fairy's mouth. It worked and she turned back to abnormal. 50% Chad pointed out they still needed to get the Galactic Egg on the asteroid. Tooth Fairy suggested using the same strategy and she beamed the egg onboard. Out of gratitude, Starfire, Freak, and Folding Paper Man knocked all their teeth out for her. During the search for the lost city of Tamaran, the crew was prey to a death trap. With a spiked ceiling descending on them, Starfire asked Tooth Fairy to find a cavity in the wall. She donned some goggles and found one. She touched it with her wand and created a hole. The crew escaped through it. They eventually defeated Blackfire and destroyed the fabled Fire Crown before she would use it to destroy Tamaran and take over the galaxy.